There has been a recent spate of things written here, there and everywhere about real boys and real men. It is a reaction to the feminization of the male that has infected American culture. These days boys are to be diagnosed with ADD or ADHD and drugged into stupor and men are to be taught to cry in public at the whim of any female. Violence of any kind is to be roundly condemned and we are told that the only thing worth studying in college is Peace Studies with a minor in Lesbian Poetry.
Real men—military guys, cowboys, meat eaters, gun owners and whiskey drinkers—are to be substituted with metrosexual-men—queer eyes for straight guys, public pouters, vegetarians, Chablis drinkers, lisping and swishy sorts and Oprah watchers.
There have appeared books to remedy such anti-male agit-prop, such as The Dangerous Book For Boys, and many lists of things ‘real men’ are supposed to do. Here is an old list from Robert Heinlein.
A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly.
Here is a new list from Popular Mechanics.
Patch a radiator hose, protect your computer, rescue a boater who has capsized, frame a wall, retouch digital photos, back up a trailer, build a campfire, fix a dead outlet, navigate with a map and compass, use a torque wrench, sharpen a knife, perform CPR, fillet a fish, maneuver a car out of a skid, get a car unstuck, back up data, paint a room, mix concrete, clean a bolt-action rifle, change oil and filter, hook up an HDTV, bleed brakes, paddle a canoe, fix a bike flat, extend your wireless network.
Before any males start to cry and lament their supposed lack of the manly arts, they need to remember that these sorts of lists are geared to the times. They no more apply to all men in all ages than do trends in male sartorial elegance. Consider the greatest society of men that ever existed, the Roman Republic (509 – 30 BC).
Here indeed was a men’s club of men’s clubs, any member of which would put to shame most of today’s mincing and prancing delicate little dandies whose claim to maleness rests solely upon the possession of a penis. So few Roman men could perform those things above, yet they brought the entire ancient world under their thumb.
Here is a list of things every Roman male over the age of 18 needed to know in 100 BC.
Handle a short sword, throw a javelin, walk 30 miles a day with full military panoply, bake bread on the march, build a small city every night, sew and repair clothing and sandals, work in teams of 100, handle mules, be accustomed to slaying men while stepping in urine, intestines and feces, kill men until the centurion tells you to stop, build and repair siege machines, siege works and artillery on the fly, become a master at taking well-defended towns, become acquainted with the price and maintenance of slaves around the Mediterranean, become expert at pick, axe and shovel, be well-rehearsed at close order drill, small infantry tactics and hand-to-hand combat, plant and harvest wheat, understand political propaganda, obey orders, give orders, construct latrines, forts, roads and aqueducts.
Not too shabby, all things considered. And who among us outside of the US Marines can do many of these today?
A list of what a real man needs to know should be tied to the nature of ‘maleness,’ an immutable thing which has not changed since Cain clobbered Abel. We men are simple creatures, and whatever things we absolutely and positively must know needs to be arranged around our nature, which is—and ladies, please take notes—based on the following:
We are naturally aggressive, competitive and violent. Any sort of gooey, multicultural and PC pap that tries to remove such behavior will only ruin the lives of those poor males who are forced to undergo such idiocy as non-competitive ‘sports’ and ‘transgender’ training. A male adapted to such feminist propaganda is scarcely qualified to fornicate, yet alone act like a man.
We like noisy stuff—guns and NASCAR and Bruce Willis movies.
We like to protect stuff—our homes, our women, our children and our nation. Even the most degraded lesbian, if her neighborhood is invaded by 100,000 Chinese soldiers, would rather be defended by a bunch of Oklahoma boys than by the questionable males who inhabit San Francisco and New York.
We respond to words like Honor, Loyalty and Duty. We don’t really get Chastity too well, but here is where real women are needed to teach it to us. We can learn it if you ladies are patient.
We react to fleshy things like food and sex. You ladies, while courting us, should encourage one part of our flesh—the food part—and deny us the other—the sex part—until we marry you. Most modern ‘Sex and the City’ women get this exactly backwards. These poor females end up as well-used and well-divorced skanks, lonely and empty wombed like Maureen Dowd.
We need to be in the wilds with other real men from time to time. Thus our habit of taking trucks, buddies, six-packs and guns into the woods. Do not try and deny this to us. If we did not do this you would love us less—or not at all.
But all of this can really be boiled down to a single sentence. It was spoken by the most complete Man who ever lived. His advice on masculinity was simple:
A man should love the Lord with all his heart.
Everything else is extra credit.
(Hat tip: Sippican Cottage.)
(Update: And since I brought it up, here—in no particular order of importance—is my own list.)
A man should know how to:
Shoot a pistol, prepare meals, handle a manual transmission 4-wheel drive truck, talk to God, clean a home, read and understand history, administer basic emergency medical care, walk ten miles a day with full pack for at least two weeks, set up any tent in any weather, save a drowning man, teach an adolescent about his life and times, read and understand women, handle teenagers in the wilds, work a machete, repair a camp stove, tent, pack and boots while in the woods, run 5 miles, swim one mile and bike 20 miles all without a break, ride a motorcycle, set up and operate computers, explain the purposes of music, literature and art, laugh easily, tell the difference between sham and real, survive alone for days at a time, recover when defeated or lost, cook meals on long trips in the wilderness, handle unexpected encounters with dangerous animals.
I can do all the above, but only a great fool will trust me with hammer, saw and drill.
11 Comments;
OK, so I can do a lot of the things mentioned in Heinlein’s list. Almost all of them, as a matter of fact. I can’t butcher a hog, but that’s about it.
And I’m going to hook up with…who, exactly?
Modern women can no more cook, sew and make a warm and loving home than they can fly to the moon. Men lost the ability to do these things when all of us decided to become a cross between oversexed, adolescent boys and narcissistic whiners.
Dear KT Cat:
I can do a bit more than half, but I will never learn to conn a ship. I hate boats. (Must have been that little incident in a tropical storm while in a tiny craft of the coast of Honduras…)
Real men and real women are making a comeback. It had to happen, as human nature can only be perverted for so long before it reacts.
As far as finding a mate…I never had trouble finding such but keeping them was another matter. Now at 54 I am retired from such cares. A great weight has been lifted from my shoulders. Odd that I would rather read than chase women.
Ironically, my comment was pretty much just a load carping and whining itself. If you want to meet a woman who carries the traditional role to an art form, check out this blog.
http://scribbit.blogspot.com/
She’s something else.
As for chasing women, that will have to wait for another day. At least I’m old and scarred enough now to do a pretty good job of getting a read on them.
Dear KT Cat:
I do my share of whining and carping, but usually only to God. A friend of mine at work comes in handy as well—and I have bent his ear more than once!
I enjoyed very much reading the lady’s writing. She is a jewel, her husband chose wisely and her children are blessed.
Celibacy is not as nearly hard as I had thought. Chastity is about impossible, however. But I keep trying.
Dude, Scribbit is the Cullinan diamond, make no mistake.
Dear KT Cat:
No doubt true. But I keep away from the good ones as well as the bad ones. My soul depends upon it.
Liked your take on Real Men. I am involved with a mentoring group and we are trying to develop a program that addresses the PM list and Heinlein’s list. We hope to develop a four year program (high school) that might produce capable “Real Men”. http://www.heinleinman.blogspot.com/
Dear Lester:
You as well have a handle on how to make boys into men. In these feminized times we have our work cut out for us.
Pingback: From the Blogosphere: Real Men « Veni, Vidi, Voce
[IF]
If you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you,
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you
But make allowance for their doubting too,
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or being lied about, don’t deal in lies,
Or being hated, don’t give way to hating,
And yet don’t look too good, nor talk too wise:
If you can dream–and not make dreams your master,
If you can think–and not make thoughts your aim;
If you can meet with Triumph and Disaster
And treat those two impostors just the same;
If you can bear to hear the truth you’ve spoken
Twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools,
Or watch the things you gave your life to, broken,
And stoop and build ’em up with worn-out tools:
If you can make one heap of all your winnings
And risk it all on one turn of pitch-and-toss,
And lose, and start again at your beginnings
And never breath a word about your loss;
If you can force your heart and nerve and sinew
To serve your turn long after they are gone,
And so hold on when there is nothing in you
Except the Will which says to them: “Hold on!”
If you can talk with crowds and keep your virtue,
Or walk with kings–nor lose the common touch,
If neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you;
If all men count with you, but none too much,
If you can fill the unforgiving minute
With sixty seconds’ worth of distance run,
Yours is the Earth and everything that’s in it,
And–which is more–you’ll be a Man, my son!
–Rudyard Kipling
Dear jiri:
Every graduation at the American school in Buenos Aires this poem would be read. Most of the graduates could scarcely understand it, could scarcely understand what it meant to be men. But some did.